Happy Easter, music lovers! As the holiday weekend winds down, and the chocolate haze begins to clear, it’s the perfect moment to reflect on a musical masterpiece that truly embodies the spirit of Easter, even more so than any sugary treat. I’m talking about none other than Andrew Lloyd Webber’s groundbreaking rock opera, Jesus Christ Superstar.
When considering an Easter-appropriate musical, the choice was clear. Jesus Christ Superstar isn’t just an option; it’s the quintessential Easter musical. It delves into the narrative heart of the holiday, reminding us that beyond the bunnies and eggs, Easter is fundamentally about the story of Jesus Christ. And while I’m sure Jesus wouldn’t begrudge a bit of chocolate indulgence in his name – he always struck me as a pretty cool guy – the core message is undeniably about his journey.
So, in the spirit of musical appreciation and holiday reflection, we’re diving deep into the discography of this iconic show. Today, I’m ranking every single song from Jesus Christ Superstar, offering my personal take on each track in this unforgettable rock opera.
A quick note on versions: For this ranking, I’m sticking with the version that has been my soundtrack for years – the original 1970 concept album. This iconic recording stars Ian Gillan as Jesus and Murray Head as Judas, and it’s the raw, electric energy of this version that truly captures the essence of Jesus Christ Superstar for me. While stage productions and film adaptations have added and tweaked songs over the years, this concept album remains the definitive article, the bedrock upon which the musical was built. So, if your favorite stage version track is missing, apologies in advance, but we’re going back to the roots with this ranking. Let’s get into it!
Ian Gillan and Murray Head in Jesus Christ Superstar concept album cover, highlighting the original superstar vocalists
The Bottom Tier: Songs I Skip
18. “Pilate’s Dream,” “Everything’s Alright (Reprise)”, “The Crucifixion”, and “John Nineteen Forty-One”
Let’s kick things off with the songs that, in all honesty, rarely make it into my regular Jesus Christ Superstar rotation. These are the tracks I tend to skip, the ones that, for various reasons, just haven’t grabbed me over the years. “Pilate’s Dream,” “Everything’s Alright (Reprise),” “The Crucifixion,” and “John Nineteen Forty-One” fall into this category.
Now, I know what some of you might be thinking, especially about “The Crucifixion.” Yes, I am fully aware of its narrative significance as the climax of the story. However, as a song, it simply doesn’t resonate with me in the same way as others on this list. Sometimes, even pivotal moments in a story don’t translate into my personal favorite musical moments. There’s no deep analysis here; these songs just don’t click with my personal taste.
17. “Everything’s Alright”
“Everything’s Alright” teeters on the edge of the “skip” list, but it earns a slight reprieve. While it’s not a track I actively seek out to listen to, it holds a different kind of value for me. I occasionally find myself playing it on the piano. This instrumental connection, however infrequent, elevates it just above the bottom tier. It’s a pleasant enough melody, and clearly serves its purpose in the narrative, but as a standalone “Superstar Song,” it’s not a standout for me.
Solidly Mid-Tier: Good Songs, But Not Game-Changers
16. “The Arrest” and “Peter’s Denial”
Moving into the realm of songs I do listen to, but perhaps not with fervent regularity, we have “The Arrest” and “Peter’s Denial.” These are both undeniably solid tracks, and crucial for driving the plot forward. They serve their narrative purpose effectively, but they don’t necessarily leap out as iconic “superstar song” moments on their own.
Of the two, I have a slight preference for “The Arrest.” There’s a fascinating dramatic tension created by the ensemble’s almost journalistic questioning of Jesus. And let’s talk about that one unnamed ensemble member who bursts in with, “There he is! They’re all asleep, the fools!” Who is this guy? He delivers such an iconic, almost comic-relief line in a moment of high drama. For me, that single line injects so much personality and intrigue into the song.
15. “Pilate and Christ” and “Trial Before Pilate (Including the 39 Lashes)”
These two tracks are grouped together because, in my mind, they function as essentially one extended song. Yes, they are listed as separate tracks, and yes, Herod’s interlude sits between them in the narrative, but musically, they feel intrinsically linked. Trying to separate “Pilate and Christ” and “Trial Before Pilate” feels like splitting hairs.
As a combined piece, it’s a decent, mid-ranking song. It effectively portrays the escalating tension and Pilate’s internal conflict, but it doesn’t quite reach the heights of the truly exceptional tracks in Jesus Christ Superstar. Therefore, as a single, somewhat average entity in my personal ranking, “Pilate and Christ/Trial Before Pilate” lands squarely in the middle.
14. “The Last Supper”
I’m largely a fan of “The Last Supper.” The chorus is undeniably catchy – an earworm that burrows its way into your brain and stays there. And the dramatic confrontation between Judas and Jesus at the song’s core is pure theatrical gold. The complex, fraught relationship between these two is arguably the most compelling element of Jesus Christ Superstar, and this song showcases it brilliantly.
However, “The Last Supper” suffers from a bit of bloat. Clocking in at around seven minutes, it feels unnecessarily long. While the choruses are addictive, their repetition starts to diminish their impact over such an extended duration. A tighter, more concise edit – perhaps trimming a chorus or two – would elevate this song considerably and make it a more consistently engaging listening experience.
13. “What’s the Buzz/Strange Thing Mystifying”
One thing Andrew Lloyd Webber consistently nails is the art of the ensemble number. He has a knack for crafting melodies that, through repetition, become utterly and irresistibly catchy. “What’s the Buzz/Strange Thing Mystifying” is a prime example of this. It’s pure ear candy. Listen to it once, and you’ll find yourself humming it for hours.
However, beyond its infectious catchiness, the song is somewhat lacking in depth. It’s a great example of Webber’s melodic genius, but it doesn’t offer much in terms of lyrical or emotional complexity. Its sheer singalong quality is enough to lift it above the lower-ranked songs, but ultimately, its relative shallowness keeps it in the lower half of this list.
12. “I Don’t Know How to Love Him”
“I Don’t Know How to Love Him” is undoubtedly one of the most famous songs from Jesus Christ Superstar. Mary Magdalene’s heartfelt ballad of burgeoning love for Jesus, delivered as he conveniently takes a nap, is a moment of quiet reflection amidst the surrounding drama. (The timing is a bit odd for a love song, admittedly, but we’ll roll with it.)
It’s undeniably catchy – again, try to find a Webber song that isn’t at least a little catchy – but as love songs go, it’s always left me a bit emotionally detached. Perhaps it’s because, in my reading of the musical, the true dramatic and emotional core lies in the Judas/Jesus dynamic. Mary Magdalene’s affections, while sweet, feel somewhat secondary. Yvonne Elliman’s vocal performance is lovely, but it lacks the raw angst and intensity that Murray Head brings to his numbers.
11. “Simon Zealotes/Poor Jerusalem”
Similar to “What’s the Buzz,” “Simon Zealotes/Poor Jerusalem” is another ensemble-driven track that leverages repetition for maximum impact. However, in this case, I find the technique even more effective. The opening section of the song brilliantly captures the escalating frenzy and fervor of the crowd. There’s something genuinely unsettling about their increasingly insistent chanting for Jesus.
The “Poor Jerusalem” section, however, does slightly deflate the momentum for me. It shifts the tone and energy in a way that feels a little less compelling than the driving intensity of the “Simon Zealotes” section. But overall, the song effectively conveys the volatile public mood and Jesus’s growing unease.
Top 10 Territory: Where the Superstar Songs Truly Shine
10. “King Herod’s Song”
“King Herod’s Song” is a perfectly crafted villain song. It provides Herod with a fantastic opportunity to be gleefully villainous and mocking, it’s surprisingly Biblically grounded, and it’s an absolute bop. The definitive version, of course, is the one featuring Alice Cooper as Herod (though that’s not on the original concept album we’re focusing on here). Alice Cooper as Herod? Come on, it’s iconic.
Even without Cooper’s legendary presence, the song is inherently fun and darkly humorous. In just over three minutes, it allows Herod to establish himself as one of the most memorable villains in the entire show, a masterclass in theatrical villainy condensed into a single, brilliant song.
9. “Judas’s Death”
Now we’re entering the truly exceptional territory, the top-tier musical numbers that make Jesus Christ Superstar the masterpiece it is. Kicking off this section is “Judas’s Death,” an emotional rollercoaster of a song. Webber masterfully delves into the profound emotional burden Judas carries as a pivotal figure in the unfolding events. His internal struggle with guilt and the weight of his actions is palpable, making this one of the most emotionally resonant songs in the entire show.
The use of repetition is particularly effective here. The recurring lines, “I have been spattered with innocent blood,” and his accusatory cries that Jesus has “murdered” him, gain power and poignancy with each iteration. And let’s not ignore the fact that Judas subtly reprises Mary Magdalene’s love song within this number, further amplifying the homoerotic subtext that simmers beneath the surface of Jesus Christ Superstar. Just saying.
8. “Overture”
Yes, I’m including the “Overture” in this ranking, and yes, it deserves its place here. Simply put, it totally slaps. Andrew Lloyd Webber is the undisputed king of bombastic overtures, and while this one might not quite reach the operatic grandeur of the Phantom of the Opera overture, it’s still a hardcore rock instrumental that sets the stage perfectly.
It’s not just the electric guitars; it’s the sheer epic scope and energy of the piece. It’s a bold, declarative statement right from the start, announcing the rock opera aesthetic with unapologetic force and launching the show with a jolt of pure adrenaline.
7. “Hosanna”
I can’t fully articulate why I adore this version of “Hosanna” so much, but something about it just clicks perfectly for me. Perhaps it’s the brief, jarring interruption from Caiaphas and the priests, injecting a dose of villainy into the celebratory atmosphere. Maybe it’s the unexpected flash of sass from Jesus himself, showcasing a flicker of human impatience amidst the adulation. Or perhaps it’s simply my aforementioned weakness for Webber’s expertly crafted ensemble numbers.
Whatever the precise combination of factors, “Hosanna” is a consistently joyous and engaging listen. It captures the fervor of the crowds and the complex emotions swirling around Jesus in this pivotal moment of his story.
6. “Superstar”
Here it is, the song that lends its name to the very concept of a “superstar song” within the musical – “Superstar.” Perhaps surprisingly, I’m placing it just outside the top five. Don’t get me wrong, it’s an absolute bop. It’s undeniably catchy, and it lays out the central thesis of the entire show with crystal clarity. It’s the song that asks, “Jesus Christ, Superstar – do you think you’re who they say you are?”
But while it’s intellectually and musically brilliant, it doesn’t quite punch me in the emotional gut in the same way as the next five songs on this list. It’s a fantastic song, a cornerstone of the musical, but for me, it’s not quite in that ultimate top tier of emotional resonance.
The Top 5: True Masterpieces of Musical Theatre
5. “The Temple”
And here we arrive at my absolute favorite ensemble number in Jesus Christ Superstar: “The Temple.” Every single element of this song is flawlessly executed. From the sinister, almost predatory haggling of the merchants who have corrupted the temple, to the sheer rock star energy of Jesus’s explosive entrance and his righteous destruction of the market stalls (and those incredible high notes!), it’s a whirlwind of musical and dramatic intensity.
The shift to the initially inspiring, but quickly turning terrifying, pleas of the crowd begging Jesus to heal them, and then Ian Gillan’s primal scream on the final line – it’s overwhelming, but in the best possible way. It’s a song of immense power and perfectly balanced chaos, a true tour-de-force.
4. “Damned For All Time/Blood Money”
Just like “Judas’s Death,” “Damned For All Time/Blood Money” is a song that hits me right in the emotional core. Murray Head delivers a performance of raw, visceral angst. The song offers a surprisingly sympathetic and nuanced portrayal of Judas’s motivations and the agonizing internal conflict that drives him to betray Jesus. It humanizes history’s ultimate villain, revealing the pain and torment behind his actions. It’s a powerful exploration of moral complexity, and I can’t help but be deeply moved by it.
3. “Heaven On Their Minds”
Okay, let’s just state it plainly: I’m a huge Murray Head as Judas fan. Deal with it. He’s simply too phenomenal to not feature prominently in my top three. The decision to make Judas the de facto narrator of Jesus Christ Superstar is a stroke of genius, and Head seizes the opportunity with both hands. His opening number, “Heaven On Their Minds,” is a bombastic, electrifying introduction to his character and his perspective.
I’m also, perhaps inexplicably, mildly obsessed with the way he pronounces “Jesus” in this song. It’s dripping with angst, laced with rock-star swagger, and it elevates the entire performance. That single vocal inflection almost single-handedly propels this song above “Damned For All Time/Blood Money,” which is no small feat.
2. “This Jesus Must Die”
What can I say? I’m a sucker for a good villain song, and “This Jesus Must Die” is a great villain song. It’s not particularly subtle or deeply layered – the title pretty much spells out the entire point – but it’s so incredibly catchy and so richly villainous in its execution that I can’t help but love it. It’s the perfect blend of ominous threat, theatrical flair, and just a touch of campy silliness. It just works, brilliantly.
1. “Gethsemane (I Only Want To Say)”
And here we have it, the undisputed masterpiece of Jesus Christ Superstar, the number one “superstar song” in a show full of them: “Gethsemane (I Only Want To Say).” Jesus’s soliloquy in the Garden of Gethsemane is a breathtaking emotional journey, a five-minute encapsulation of the five stages of grief, and a profound exploration of faith, doubt, and sacrifice.
Ian Gillan’s vocal performance is nothing short of iconic, perfectly conveying the agonizing weight of Jesus’s awareness of his impending crucifixion. His rock star screams are not just displays of vocal prowess; they are raw, visceral expressions of pain and resignation. “Gethsemane” is the perfect synthesis of the core themes of Easter, both within the context of the musical and in a broader spiritual sense. For its sheer emotional power, its musical brilliance, and its profound thematic resonance, it unequivocally deserves the top spot on this list.
And there you have it – my definitive ranking of every song from Jesus Christ Superstar. Now it’s your turn! Head down to the comments and let me know your rankings. Do you agree with my top picks? Are there any songs you think I’ve unfairly overlooked? Let’s get the discussion going!
Happy Easter once again, and until next time, keep the music playing!
Share this:
Like Loading…
