Ranking The Beach Boys Songs: From Surf Rock Classics to Hidden Gems

The Beach Boys are an American institution, synonymous with sun-drenched California summers and the optimistic spirit of the 1960s. But beyond the surf anthems and car songs lies a rich and complex catalog of music that spans genres, emotions, and decades. Exploring the Beach Boys songs reveals a journey of innovation, experimentation, and profound musicality that continues to resonate with listeners today. From their early surf rock days to the groundbreaking sounds of Pet Sounds and beyond, the Beach Boys songs have left an indelible mark on popular music. This list delves into the very best of their discography, spotlighting not just the hits, but also the deep cuts and overlooked masterpieces that truly define the genius of the Beach Boys songs.

40. Baby Blue (1979)

Navigating the Beach Boys’ albums from the late 1970s requires a discerning ear, as inconsistency became a defining characteristic. Yet, “Baby Blue” emerges as a sparkling exception. Originally intended for Dennis Wilson’s shelved second solo album, Bamboo, it found its way onto the often-criticized LA (Light Album). This track is a gem of fragility and ethereal beauty, oscillating between romantic yearning and melancholic pain. It stands out as a testament to Dennis Wilson’s songwriting talent, even amidst a period of fluctuating creative output for the band.

39. The Lonely Sea (1963)

Hidden within the energetic surf instrumentals and upbeat odes to wave riding on the Surfin’ USA album, “The Lonely Sea” presents a striking contrast. This track is slow, shimmering, and possesses an eerie quality that sets it apart. It evokes a sense of the ocean as something subtly menacing, a reminder of life’s fleeting nature, rather than just a source of carefree fun. The dreamy melancholy of “The Lonely Sea” offers a glimpse into the introspective direction Brian Wilson was beginning to explore, hinting at the deeper musical territories he would soon conquer.

38. Disney Girls (1957) (1971)

Bruce Johnston’s songwriting contributions to the Beach Boys could occasionally veer into sentimentality, as exemplified by tracks like “Deirdre” from Sunflower. However, “Disney Girls (1957)”, from the Surf’s Up album, showcases a more refined and genuinely charming side of his artistry. The gentle, descending melody of this song evokes a nostalgic vision of 1950s America, a theme decidedly unfashionable in 1971. Despite the era and the addition of wah-wah guitar, the song’s disarming sweetness and nostalgic charm endure, making it a unique and endearing piece within the Beach Boys’ catalog.

37. Wind Chimes (1967)

LSD’s impact on Brian Wilson was far from a relaxing, carefree experience; it was, by his own account, deeply unsettling. This unease is palpable in “Wind Chimes,” a track initially conceived for the ill-fated Smile project. The original Smile version is compellingly creepy in its supine and fragmented structure, but the ragged re-recording on Smiley Smile amplifies this unsettling atmosphere even further. “Wind Chimes” stands as a singular creation in the Beach Boys’ discography, unlike anything else they ever recorded, reflecting the turbulent inner world of its creator.

36. Little Honda (1964)

A studio disagreement between Brian and Carl Wilson arose over “Little Honda,” with Brian insisting on incorporating a distorted guitar sound. Brian’s vision prevailed, and the result pushed the Beach Boys closer to garage-rock territory than ever before. While not quite as raw as bands like the Shadows of Knight, “Little Honda” possesses a thrilling hint of pounding aggression that is unusual and exciting within their typically sunnier sound. This track demonstrates their ability to experiment with a tougher, more energetic edge.

35. It’s About Time (1970)

Rocking out convincingly wasn’t generally the Beach Boys’ strength; their musical talents lay elsewhere. This makes “It’s About Time,” a collaborative effort involving Dennis and Carl Wilson and Al Jardine, a rare and delightful surprise. Dennis Wilson’s vocal performance is raw and powerful, the guitar solo delivers a sharp sting, and the Santana-influenced Latin percussion adds a dynamic rattle. “It’s About Time” is a standout track showcasing a harder-rocking side of the band that is both unexpected and highly enjoyable.

34. Be True To Your School (1963)

The Beach Boys lineup featuring Carl Wilson, Mike Love, Dennis Wilson, Brian Wilson, and David Marks. Photograph: Michael Ochs Archives/Getty Images

Mike Love remains a figure of debate among Beach Boys enthusiasts, yet his contribution to “Be True to Your School” is undeniable and electrifying. His lyrics carry an unexpected belligerence, delivered with a punkish snarl that clashes intriguingly with the song’s perky cheerleader chants and “ra-ra” backing vocals. It’s as if Love intended to provoke a confrontation rather than simply celebrate school spirit. This tension between the aggressive vocals and upbeat music makes “Be True to Your School” a uniquely compelling and exciting track.

33. Wendy (1964)

“Wendy” was conceived as an homage to the Beach Boys’ East Coast rivals, the Four Seasons. The influence of the Four Seasons’ hit “Ronnie” is evident, particularly in the song’s introduction. However, while the Four Seasons evoked the overcast toughness of Newark, “Wendy” replaces this with a dreamy melancholy that feels sunlit even as it contemplates a future that appears “awful dim.” This blend of sunny instrumentation and wistful undertones is a hallmark of the Beach Boys’ ability to infuse their music with emotional depth.

32. Cuddle Up (1972)

The often-overlooked album Carl and the Passions – So Tough shares a distant kinship with 1965’s Beach Boys Today! Both albums feature a second side dedicated to ballads, but on So Tough, these ballads are darker and wearier, reflecting a band deeply marked by the excesses of the late 1960s. The standout track is “Cuddle Up,” a gorgeous and battered romantic ballad sung by Dennis Wilson. It captures a mood of bruised tenderness and stands as a highpoint in the album’s exploration of more somber themes.

31. Help Me, Rhonda (1965)

Despite a reputation for being square – his LA hipster associates often mocked his perceived lack of sophistication – Brian Wilson was a significant risk-taker in the studio. The original version of “Help Me, Rhonda” exemplifies this, featuring a final minute that inexplicably fades in and out. Even without this unusual coda, the single version is excellent, characterized by lyrical misery that sharply contrasts with the upbeat melody. This juxtaposition of sadness and catchy pop is a hallmark of Brian Wilson’s songwriting genius.

30. Summer’s Gone (2012)

That’s Why God Made the Radio is an album of uneven quality, yet the final track, “Summer’s Gone,” serves as a perfect and poignant farewell, especially considering it’s likely to be the last Beach Boys album. Built around a keyboard motif that echoes the introduction of “California Girls,” it effectively repurposes Brian Wilson’s signature melancholy. “Summer’s Gone” is a beautifully crafted and emotionally resonant conclusion to their recorded legacy, reflecting on time passing and the bittersweet nature of endings.

29. Little Deuce Coupe (1963)

The melody of “Little Deuce Coupe” is among Brian Wilson’s simpler compositions, and the lyrics are essentially someone enthusiastically rambling about their car, detailing everything from the clutch to the registration. Yet, the result is a concise 1 minute and 44 seconds of pure, life-affirming joy. This track exemplifies the Beach Boys’ mysterious alchemical power in 1963 – their ability to transform simple elements into something utterly uplifting and infectious.

28. Time to Get Alone (1969)

The 20/20 album, released in 1969, is a mixed bag, featuring older outtakes, cover songs, a recording of Dennis Wilson’s intimate moments, and, notably, songwriting contributions from Charles Manson. Buried among these eclectic tracks is “Time to Get Alone,” a Brian Wilson song expressing a longing for escape, “safe from the people.” It’s an airily delightful track, elevated by a chorus that feels like a heavenly sigh. “Time to Get Alone” is a hidden gem within a somewhat disjointed album, showcasing Brian’s consistent songwriting brilliance.

27. 4th of July (1971)

The Beach Boys in London in 1970, featuring Bruce Johnston, Carl Wilson, Mike Love, Al Jardine, and Dennis Wilson. Photograph: Gijsbert Hanekroot/Redferns

Dennis Wilson established himself as a significant songwriting force with “Forever” on the Sunflower album, but “4th of July” is arguably even more powerful. It’s an epic and deeply troubled meditation on the Vietnam War, a stark departure from the Beach Boys’ earlier image as “America’s Band.” “Band politics” led to its exclusion from Surf’s Up, and it remained unreleased until 1993. “4th of July” reveals a previously unseen depth and social consciousness in the Beach Boys’ music, making it a significant and impactful song.

26. Dance, Dance, Dance (1964)

“Dance, Dance, Dance” might be undervalued within the Beach Boys’ impressive run of classic singles, simply due to the high caliber of the company it keeps. Carl Wilson’s guitar riff is exceptional, and the 12-string guitar and frantic solo clearly show the influence of the Beatles’ “A Hard Day’s Night.” However, the sudden key change in the middle of the third verse is pure Brian Wilson innovation. This blend of rock and roll energy with Brian’s unique harmonic sensibility makes “Dance, Dance, Dance” a standout track.

25. The Warmth of the Sun (1964)

Reportedly written in response to the assassination of President John F. Kennedy, “The Warmth of the Sun” is remarkably lush and profoundly sad. It also perfectly illustrates the subtle yet significant growth in Brian Wilson’s songwriting sophistication. In 1964, no other pop songwriter was crafting chord progressions and melodies with such richness and emotional depth. “The Warmth of the Sun” is a testament to Brian’s evolving artistry and his ability to convey complex emotions through music.

24. Darlin’ (1967)

By the time Wild Honey was released in December 1967, the Beach Boys were facing challenges: Brian Wilson’s mental health had deteriorated, and critics deemed them out of touch. Yet, “Darlin’,” with its heart-swelling triumph and Carl Wilson’s powerful vocal performance, belies these struggles. In its own way, its pared-back, R&B-infused sound aligned with the emerging rootsy, post-psychedelic musical landscape. “Darlin'” is an uplifting and resilient track that showcases the band’s enduring vitality even during turbulent times.

23. Feel Flows (1971)

Carl Wilson, known for his angelic vocals, was a sporadically developing songwriter. “Feel Flows,” however, is a complete delight. It’s a hazily psychedelic take on laid-back 1970s West Coast rock, featuring a fantastic and surprisingly biting guitar solo. Its inclusion in the film Almost Famous deservedly brought it to a wider audience. “Feel Flows” is a testament to Carl’s songwriting potential and a highlight of the Beach Boys’ more experimental 70s work.

22. This Whole World (1970)

Legend has it that Brian Wilson wrote “This Whole World” while “stoned and confused,” which seems remarkable considering the song’s intricate changes and its spiraling sense of elation. The a cappella coda – Carl’s soaring falsetto layered over a wall of backing vocals – is as spine-tingling as any moment in the entire Beach Boys catalog. “This Whole World” is a vibrant and complex track that defies its purported origins, demonstrating Brian Wilson’s enduring musical genius even in unconventional circumstances.

21. I’m Waiting For the Day (1966)

Pet Sounds is consistently brilliant, making the selection of highlights a matter of personal taste. Is “I’m Waiting For the Day” objectively “better” than “I Guess I Just Wasn’t Made For These Times” or “Here Today”? Not necessarily, but the moment at 0:52 when the drums enter might be the album’s most exhilarating and exuberant peak. “I’m Waiting For the Day” is a powerful and dynamic track within an album already overflowing with musical riches, showcasing the Beach Boys’ ability to create moments of pure sonic joy.

20. Let Him Run Wild (1965)

“Let Him Run Wild” is a wonderful song and another clear precursor to Pet Sounds, blending the influence of Burt Bacharach into a narrative of heartbreak and optimism. The songwriting and arrangements are increasingly ornate, but Brian Wilson’s true genius may lie not just in the musical twists and turns but in how effortlessly the final product feels. “Let Him Run Wild” is a sophisticated and emotionally resonant track that foreshadows the groundbreaking sounds to come.

19. Sail On Sailor (1973)

The demo of “Sail On Sailor” features Brian Wilson pleading with co-writer Van Dyke Parks to “convince me that I’m not insane.” That such an optimistic and uplifting song emerged from such personal turmoil is almost unbelievable. The lyrics might reflect Parks’s message to his troubled collaborator, but Brian’s assertive and punchy music perfectly complements them. “Sail On Sailor” is a song of resilience and hope, born from struggle, and a testament to the power of music to overcome adversity.

18. Fun, Fun, Fun (1964)

“Fun, Fun, Fun” must have sounded like a description of an alien world to early 1960s Britain: a land of drive-in restaurants and unimaginable abundance, where a teenager could own a Ford Thunderbird. It’s no surprise the song sounds so exuberant, from its Chuck Berry-esque guitar intro to its final, life-affirming explosion of harmonies. “Fun, Fun, Fun” captures the youthful exuberance and optimistic spirit of early 60s America in a way that is both timeless and irresistibly catchy.

17. All I Wanna Do (1970)

Often overshadowed by its successor Surf’s Up, Sunflower is arguably the true gem of the Beach Boys’ 1970s catalog. More of a band effort than Pet Sounds, it’s packed with incredible songs, notably “All I Wanna Do.” This track is a blissful, reverb-drenched dream that some have identified as a precursor to chillwave. Brian Wilson, somewhat bafflingly, later dismissed it as “boring.” “All I Wanna Do” is a serene and innovative track that deserves wider recognition for its beauty and influence.

16. Surfin’ USA (1963)

Brian Wilson, a remarkably fast learner in pop music, described 1962’s “Surfin’ Safari” as merely “a rehearsal.” The qualitative leap to “Surfin’ USA,” released just five months later and indebted to Chuck Berry, is astounding. It’s tighter, smoother, shinier, and more exciting – a song perfectly capturing its moment, yet so infectiously gleeful it transcends time. “Surfin’ USA” is a definitive surf rock anthem and a testament to the rapid artistic growth of the Beach Boys in their early years.

15. Heroes and Villains (1967)

“Heroes and Villains,” intended as the follow-up to “Good Vibrations,” pushed Brian Wilson’s fragmented songwriting technique to its limits. More disjointed than its predecessor, it remains an incredible achievement, unlike anything else in pop music then or now. What 1967 audiences would have made of the five-minute version, finally released in 2011, is anyone’s guess. “Heroes and Villains” is a bold and experimental track that showcases Brian Wilson’s ambition and willingness to push the boundaries of pop music.

14. Do It Again (1968)

Harking back to the early 1960s even as the decade was ending, “Do It Again” helped initiate a retrospective mood in US pop culture, recalling a mythic, innocent era, much like American Graffiti and Don McLean’s “American Pie” would later do. It’s also a fantastic song in its own right, with a particularly thrilling lead vocal-free middle section. “Do It Again” is a nostalgic and expertly crafted track that reflects on the past while remaining firmly rooted in its own time.

13. In My Room (1963)

“In My Room” is the most poignant and moving of the Beach Boys’ initial forays into introspection. With its themes of worries, fears, and crying in the dark, it feels surprisingly vulnerable for a male pop band in 1963. This track is an early indication that the sunny California image might not reveal the full story, hinting at deeper emotional complexities beneath the surface. “In My Room” is a groundbreaking and deeply personal song that marked a significant shift in the Beach Boys’ thematic approach.

12. Cabinessence (1969)

Consider Mike Love, often portrayed as the naysaying antagonist in the Smile saga, and his potential shock upon hearing “Cabinessence.” For someone seeking a hit single, it might have been jarring. However, removed from that context, “Cabinessence” sounds gloriously ambitious, drawing from folk music, cowboy songs, and Aaron Copland. It’s alternately humorous, touching, and unsettling. “Cabinessence” is a complex and richly textured piece that exemplifies the experimental and ambitious nature of the unreleased Smile project.

11. Don’t Talk (Put Your Head on My Shoulder) (1966)

“Don’t Talk (Put Your Head on My Shoulder)” is a strong contender for the title of the most beautiful song the Beach Boys ever recorded. Its sumptuous, string-laden yearning stands out even on Pet Sounds. Analyzing its harmonic intricacies, diminished chords, and passing tones is possible, but ultimately unnecessary. However Brian achieved it, the song’s emotional impact is undeniable and universally captivating. “Don’t Talk (Put Your Head on My Shoulder)” is a masterpiece of emotional expression and musical beauty.

10. Please Let Me Wonder (1965)

Side two of Beach Boys Today! presents a sequence of stunning, lush ballads that testify to Brian Wilson’s growing affinity for marijuana and served as a rehearsal for Pet Sounds. Each ballad is remarkable, but the subtly arranged and swooning beauty of “Please Let Me Wonder” is truly exceptional. “Please Let Me Wonder” is a standout example of the sophisticated and emotionally resonant balladry that Brian Wilson was perfecting during this period.

9. I Get Around (1964)

Perhaps the ultimate expression of youthful swagger in pop history – “we’ve never missed yet with the girls we meet” – “I Get Around” manages to be both incredibly self-assured and utterly irresistible. The astonishing harmonies, Brian’s soaring falsetto, the key change midway through, and the fabulous pizzicato guitar on the verses all contribute to its perfection. “I Get Around” is a quintessential Beach Boys hit that embodies youthful confidence and musical brilliance.

8. God Only Knows (1966)

In recent years, “God Only Knows” has seemingly become the definitive Beach Boys song, heard on the radio even more frequently than “I Get Around.” Despite its resulting familiarity, its plaintive loveliness, amplified by Carl Wilson’s vocal performance, can still be breathtaking in unguarded moments. “God Only Knows” is a timeless and deeply moving ballad that continues to resonate with audiences across generations, solidifying its place as a cornerstone of the Beach Boys’ legacy.

7. California Girls (1965)

“California Girls” perfectly encapsulates the contrasting personalities at the Beach Boys’ core. Mike Love’s lyrics are a swaggering tribute to the women of their home state, a blend of flirtatious admiration and boastful pride. Brian Wilson’s astonishing instrumental introduction, however, seems to originate from a different realm entirely: reflective, autumnal, and tinged with sadness. “California Girls” is a complex and multifaceted song that juxtaposes youthful exuberance with underlying emotional depth, showcasing the dynamic tension within the band’s creative forces.

6. Wouldn’t It Be Nice (1966)

“Wouldn’t It Be Nice,” Pet Sounds‘ opening track and mission statement, showcases Brian Wilson pushing every boundary. Tempo shifts, daring key changes (the first occurring just six seconds in), instruments transformed by studio techniques, and harmonies so intricate they brought Carl Wilson to tears in the studio – it all works flawlessly. “Wouldn’t It Be Nice” is an incredible song that exemplifies Brian Wilson’s studio genius and his relentless pursuit of sonic perfection.

5. Don’t Worry Baby (1966)

“Don’t Worry Baby,” one of the greatest B-sides ever, has everything: an exquisite melody made even more beautiful by Brian’s tender vocal, a lush harmonic backdrop, poignant lyrics about teen romance and a reckless drag race that seems to mirror Brian’s own anxieties and insecurities. “Don’t Worry Baby” is a deeply moving and perfectly crafted song that transcends its status as a B-side, standing as a testament to Brian Wilson’s songwriting prowess.

4. ’Til I Die (1971)

The Beach Boys lineup featuring Mike Love, Al Jardine, Brian Wilson, Carl Wilson, and Dennis Wilson in a group portrait. Photograph: Michael Ochs Archives/Getty Images

“’Til I Die,” a stunning piece of songwriting (explore the extended alternative mix on 1998’s Endless Harmony), is the most emotionally desolate song in the Beach Boys’ catalog. It’s a cry of resigned despair from a man in profound distress. Its hopelessness is chilling, yet its sonic richness is comforting, creating an incredibly potent and unsettling combination. “’Til I Die” is a deeply personal and emotionally raw song that reveals the darker undercurrents within Brian Wilson’s artistic vision.

3. Caroline, No (1966)

Almost any track from Pet Sounds could occupy this high position, but for sheer emotional impact, “Caroline, No” is hard to surpass. It’s a poignant meditation on lost innocence, equally applicable to a child or a former love. The music is sumptuously sad, and the final, agonized note of Brian’s vocal is heartbreaking. “Caroline, No” is a devastatingly beautiful and emotionally resonant song that explores themes of change and loss with unparalleled sensitivity.

2. Surf’s Up (1971)

The public first encountered “Surf’s Up” four years before its official release on the album of the same name, and it was immediately lauded. The 1967 documentary Inside Pop described it as “Too complex to get all of first time around … poetic, beautiful,” superlatives that initially horrified Brian Wilson. Yet, they are deserved. Elliptical, deeply haunting, and elegiac, “Surf’s Up” seems to anticipate the decline of the 1960s even at their peak. “Surf’s Up” is a complex and visionary track that stands as a testament to Brian Wilson’s unparalleled songwriting ambition and his ability to capture the zeitgeist of a changing era.

1. Good Vibrations (1966)

In the documentary Long Promised Road, Don Was attempts to dissect Brian Wilson’s production techniques by playing his original multi-tracks. He ultimately concedes, “I don’t know how he did that,” baffled by the complexity. “Good Vibrations” is proof of these inexplicable powers. An act of unprecedented audacity, it was pieced together from fragments recorded across four different studios. Yet, it doesn’t sound like an avant-garde experiment; it sounds like a breathtaking pop single. Its endless shifts and changes coalesce into a perfectly formed, unbelievably thrilling whole. The greatest single ever? Perhaps. The pinnacle of 1960s pop invention and daring? Probably. The Beach Boys’ crowning achievement? Absolutely. “Good Vibrations” remains a revolutionary and timeless masterpiece, solidifying its place as the ultimate Beach Boys song and a landmark achievement in pop music history.

Comments

No comments yet. Why don’t you start the discussion?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *