Music, a universal language, constantly evolves, reflecting societal shifts and individual emotions. Defining the “Most Popular Song Ever” is a fascinating, albeit complex endeavor. Popularity isn’t static; it’s a dynamic measure influenced by generations, cultures, and technological advancements in music consumption. Recently, Rolling Stone, a renowned authority in music journalism, undertook a significant project to revisit and refresh their list of the 500 Greatest Songs of All Time, initially published in 2004. This updated list offers a compelling lens through which to examine the concept of musical popularity and enduring appeal.
In the original 2004 compilation, Rolling Stone‘s selection leaned heavily towards classic rock and soul, genres that dominated much of the 20th century. However, recognizing the seismic shifts in music over the past two decades – the rise of streaming, the dominance of hip-hop, and the increasing globalization of music tastes – the publication embarked on a comprehensive reboot. To ensure the list resonated with contemporary audiences and reflected the diverse landscape of modern music, they convened a panel of over 250 artists, musicians, producers, industry experts, critics, and journalists. This diverse group, ranging from Angelique Kidjo to Zedd, and Megan Thee Stallion to Bill Ward, each submitted a ranked list of their top 50 songs. The results, tabulating nearly 4,000 song nominations, culminated in a significantly revised RS 500, offering a more inclusive and contemporary perspective on what constitutes musical greatness and, by extension, enduring popularity.
harry styles as it was
Image Credit: Youtube. Alt text: Harry Styles performing “As It Was” live, showcasing the song’s global popularity and modern pop appeal.
One of the most striking aspects of the updated list is its broadened scope. While the original list was anchored in rock and soul, the new iteration embraces a far wider spectrum of genres. Hip-hop, modern country, indie rock, Latin pop, reggae, and R&B all find significantly greater representation. This shift underscores the evolving definition of “popular music” itself. What resonates with mass audiences today is far more diverse than it was in previous decades. The inclusion of contemporary hits alongside timeless classics demonstrates that popularity isn’t solely a matter of historical impact; it’s also about current cultural relevance and resonance.
Notably, over half of the songs on the updated list are new additions, not featured in the 2004 version. Even within the Top 100, a third of the songs are fresh entries. This significant turnover highlights the dynamic nature of musical popularity. While some songs achieve timeless status and remain cultural touchstones across generations, new songs constantly emerge, capturing the zeitgeist and achieving widespread acclaim. The Rolling Stone update acknowledges this constant evolution, presenting a list that is both respectful of music history and attuned to contemporary tastes.
Consider Harry Styles’ “As It Was,” featured prominently in the updated list. This song, a recent global phenomenon, exemplifies modern pop’s ability to achieve immense popularity in a short span. Its inclusion demonstrates that “most popular” isn’t just about songs with decades of legacy; it also encompasses tracks that dominate current charts and cultural conversations. The song’s introspective lyrics, combined with its upbeat synth-pop melody, resonated deeply with a global audience, proving its immediate and widespread popularity.
late great townes van zandt
Alt text: Townes Van Zandt in a pensive portrait, representing the enduring appeal of classic songwriting and storytelling in popular music.
In contrast, the list also retains songs like Townes Van Zandt’s “Pancho and Lefty.” While not a chart-topping hit in the traditional sense, its inclusion speaks to a different kind of popularity – the enduring influence of masterful songwriting and storytelling. “Pancho and Lefty,” especially Van Zandt’s own melancholic rendition, has achieved a different kind of lasting popularity, influencing generations of songwriters and becoming a beloved classic within folk and country circles. Its popularity is measured not just in sales figures but in its profound artistic impact and continued cultural relevance.
Lizzo’s “Truth Hurts” represents another facet of modern musical popularity. Originally released in 2017 but gaining massive traction in 2019, its viral ascent to becoming a signature hit illustrates the power of online platforms and cultural moments in propelling a song to widespread recognition. “Truth Hurts” resonated with its message of self-love and empowerment, amplified by its catchy hook and Lizzo’s charismatic persona. Its journey to popularity highlights how contemporary hits can emerge and achieve massive reach through a combination of musical merit, cultural relevance, and digital virality.
496-lizzo-truth-hurts
Alt text: Lizzo performing “Truth Hurts,” capturing the song’s energetic and empowering message that contributed to its widespread popularity.
Examining the Rolling Stone list, it becomes clear that the “most popular song ever” is not a singular entity but rather a spectrum of songs achieving popularity in diverse ways and across different timeframes. Some songs achieve immediate, chart-topping popularity, reflecting current trends and tastes. Others gain popularity over time, becoming classics through their enduring musical quality and cultural impact. And some songs achieve popularity through critical acclaim and influence, shaping genres and inspiring future generations of musicians.
The updated RS 500 list is a valuable resource for anyone interested in understanding the multifaceted nature of musical popularity. It’s a conversation starter, prompting discussions about personal favorites, genre evolution, and the very definition of a “great song.” It’s a testament to the power of music to connect with audiences across time and cultures, constantly redefining what resonates and what endures. While pinpointing the single “most popular song ever” remains an elusive and perhaps subjective quest, lists like Rolling Stone‘s 500 Greatest Songs offer a rich and insightful exploration of the landscape of popular music and the songs that have, in various ways, captured the hearts and minds of millions.
