This year’s Grammy Awards presented a refreshing departure from the norm, even for someone typically outside the realm of mainstream pop. As a classically trained opera singer and voice teacher, I often find myself tuning out of the broadcast after the initial hour. Contemporary pop music, with its often simplistic songwriting – a stark contrast to the complexities of Puccini or Sondheim – and overtly sexualized performances, rarely captures my attention. My years of conservatory training and dedicated practice have instilled in me a deep appreciation for vocal nuance and artistry, sometimes leading to a sense of disconnect when observing the pop landscape. In past years, watching the Grammys has even evoked a feeling of professional discouragement, prompting questions about the relevance of my own rigorous training.
However, this year’s ceremony struck a different chord. Here’s why it resonated so strongly.
The Prevailing Power of Authentic Artistic Creation
The theme of artists forging their own unique paths was powerfully evident throughout the entire evening. Seeing Tracy Chapman perform her iconic hit “Fast Car” live was a truly moving experience. This song has been a personal favorite for years, and witnessing her deliver its haunting melody and poignant lyrics on the Grammy stage was genuinely thrilling. Joni Mitchell’s rendition of “Both Sides Now” was equally impactful, bringing tears to my eyes.
These performances sparked a powerful reflection: both Chapman and Mitchell likely crafted these timeless songs in the solitude of their own spaces, with just a guitar and a personal journal or songwriting notebook. They embodied the essence of artistic creation in its purest form, taking the courageous step of bringing their inner voices to life without knowing if their work would ever reach an audience. This act of creation, inherently vulnerable and uncertain, is at the heart of all artistic endeavors.
Then came the new wave of influential female singer-songwriters, including Olivia Rodrigo, Taylor Swift, and Billie Eilish, all of whom stand on the shoulders of giants like Mitchell and Chapman. Regardless of personal taste in their particular musical styles, it’s undeniable that these artists are risk-takers who undoubtedly began their creative journeys writing poetry and songs in their bedrooms with just a guitar or piano. This DIY ethos connects them directly to their predecessors.
When I asked my 11-year-old student about her deep admiration for Taylor Swift, she insightfully explained, “I love that she’s independent and doesn’t rely on others to create her work. She writes from her own experiences. No one else writes her songs for her.” This sentiment underscores a crucial point about authenticity in artistry. While most of us may not reach the heights of fame achieved by these Grammy stars, we all begin in the same foundational space: dedicating countless hours in private, practicing, writing, dreaming, and creating. This solitary work can often feel futile, like shouting into a void. However, I believe this creative effort is never truly wasted. Your song might be sung by someone else, resonate deeply with a listener, or spark a new realization or feeling in them. It could lead to an album, become a viral sensation on TikTok, feature in a personal family video, or simply inspire you to create even more. Every act of creation holds value. And in the case of artists like Billie Eilish, her intensely personal and unique songwriting has resonated globally, proving the power of authentic self-expression.
The Return of Vocal Artistry and “Pretty Singing”
The Grammy performances were not only emotionally resonant but also largely showcased impressive vocal technique. It was noteworthy and refreshing to hear artists embracing head voice and register shifts, moving away from the over-reliance on belting in chest voice that has become prevalent in recent years. The melodies were captivating, and the singers demonstrated impressive control and agility in navigating different vocal registers. As a voice teacher and classically trained singer, witnessing the resurgence of head voice in popular music was genuinely exciting! This shift highlights a renewed appreciation for vocal nuance and skilled singing, moving beyond mere vocal power.
In a related note, recognition is due to the Metropolitan Opera and Terence Blanchard for Champion winning Best Opera Recording, alongside all the incredible performers involved in this important work.
Honoring Musical Legacies and Predecessors
The nominees and winners throughout the evening made a point of celebrating the artists who paved the way for them. Stevie Wonder paid tribute to Tony Bennett, Oprah Winfrey and Fantasia honored Tina Turner, and Miley Cyrus celebrated Mariah Carey’s influence. Annie Lennox delivered a powerful tribute to Sinead O’Connor. Seeing Joni Mitchell, a true icon now in her octogenarian years, receive such adoration and recognition was deeply heartening. In a culture often fixated on youth, these moments of intergenerational respect and acknowledgment were incredibly moving and refreshing. This emphasis on musical lineage underscores the enduring power of music across generations.
Celebrating Individuality and Unique Artistic Voices
While acknowledging their musical influences with sincerity and respect, the new generation of female artists presented themselves with unapologetic individuality. Billie Eilish’s distinctive style and persona could not be more different from Taylor Swift’s, just as Tracy Chapman’s presence and energy are radically distinct from Tina Turner’s. Pink hair, elegant ball gowns, edgy jumpsuits – all expressions of personal style were celebrated. This diverse range of self-expression sends a powerful message to aspiring artists: authenticity is paramount. Our individual voices, bodies, perspectives, and even our hair choices are unique assets. Embracing this individuality is key to artistic impact. Billie Eilish’s songs, for example, are instantly recognizable due to her unique vocal delivery, production choices, and overall artistic aesthetic, setting her apart in the contemporary music landscape.
The Timelessness of Great Songwriting
“Both Sides Now,” penned by Joni Mitchell when she was only 23 years old, feels as relevant and contemporary today as it did upon its release. It is simply a song of exceptional quality, transcending time. This timeless quality is not unlike the enduring appeal of opera. Ultimately, the 2023 Grammys served as a powerful reminder of the enduring value of authentic artistic expression, skillful vocal performance, and, most importantly, great songwriting – qualities exemplified by artists like Billie Eilish and celebrated throughout the ceremony.
