Liverpool, the home of The Beatles, is where I grew up, so their music is deeply ingrained in my life. Like many, I have strong opinions on their albums. Rubber Soul reigns supreme for me, though I can concede arguments for Abbey Road, Sgt. Pepper’s, or Revolver. However, when it comes to their worst, it’s undoubtedly one of those movie tie-in albums forced upon them. For me, Magical Mystery Tour hits a particular low, even beneath Yellow Submarine.
While the ‘White Album’ boasts undeniable brilliance, its sprawling nature can’t match the focused artistry of The Beatles’ peak. And Magical Mystery Tour? Despite a couple of gems – it’s The Beatles, after all – it’s largely considered a misstep from a flawed project. “Fool On The Hill” is a classic, and “I Am The Walrus” has its bizarre charm. “Strawberry Fields Forever,” arguably the standout, wasn’t even intended for the album, initially released as a single. Even the band themselves were reportedly dissatisfied. If John Lennon was critical of Magical Mystery Tour, it’s safe to say it sits at the bottom of their discography for many.
Some argue for Magical Mystery Tour’s merit as a compilation, but I remain unconvinced. An album should be a cohesive journey, a deliberate exploration of sound and emotion. Magical Mystery Tour, while containing a few decent tracks, lacks this crucial album quality. Of course, musical taste is subjective, but even acknowledging hyperbole, the title track isn’t even the worst Beatles song – that dubious honor might go to “You Know My Name (Look Up The Number).” However, for this discussion, a subpar song from a rushed project driven by commercial pressures perfectly mirrors my concerns about the Minecraft movie and, crucially, its potential soundtrack, or lack thereof, of memorable Minecraft Song moments.
The Minecraft movie trailer feels off. It’s another gaming adaptation leaning into isekai tropes, with a semi-realistic take on Minecraft’s blocky world that evokes the same unsettling feeling as the initial Sonic movie design. It’s cringe-inducing.
Marketed towards children, the dialogue appears weak. The trailer features not one, but two tired “he’s behind me, isn’t he?” jokes when Jack Black’s Steve is revealed. It feels like a forced attempt at humor that misses the mark, much like the forced nature of Magical Mystery Tour.
We’re in an era where game adaptations can achieve critical and commercial success. We have the Sonic franchise, which blends humor with genuine character investment. We have prestige television like The Last of Us. Then there are misfires like Borderlands. Given these examples, why aim for the Borderlands level of quality? Why risk delivering a Minecraft movie that feels as musically uninspired as a bad Beatles B-side, devoid of a truly iconic minecraft song?
Borderlands-movie-characters
The Minecraft movie had potential. It still could be good. But the trailer is underwhelming. The CGI seems jarring, the green screens are obvious, the dialogue is clunky, and the overall impression is one of a rushed, uninspired project. If the soundtrack follows suit, lacking any memorable minecraft song or musical identity, it risks mirroring the critical fate of Magical Mystery Tour. While I might not pity Jack Black, given his career choices, the situation echoes The Beatles’ predicament: a potentially compromised creative project driven by external pressures.
Magical Mystery Tour was a rushed Beatles release to satisfy contractual obligations. The Minecraft movie, while perhaps not born from identical circumstances, currently projects a similar vibe: a hastily assembled cash grab. Let’s hope the final product, and especially its soundtrack, proves more inspired than the trailer suggests, and delivers at least one memorable minecraft song to justify its existence.
[
