The aftermath of national tragedies often prompts profound reflection within communities, including faith-based ones. In the wake of the September 11, 2001 attacks, a significant discussion arose within my church, located in a New York City suburb, regarding the appropriateness of incorporating American Patriotic Songs into our worship services. This request initiated a period of thoughtful consideration, leading me to explore the theological and practical dimensions of this issue. The questions and answers that follow represent my initial reflections from September 29, 2001, just eighteen days after the World Trade Center attacks. While not exhaustive, they offer a framework for navigating the complexities of patriotic expression within the context of Christian worship.
Examining the Scriptural Basis for Patriotic Songs in Worship
1. Is there a biblical mandate for singing patriotic songs in church?
Answer: No, scripture does not explicitly command the inclusion of patriotic songs in worship services. The Bible does not prescribe singing songs specifically dedicated to nationalistic themes or anthems in the context of worship.
2. Does the Bible provide examples of patriotic songs being sung?
Answer: The Bible does not offer direct examples of patriotic songs in the way we understand them today. While some Psalms and Old Testament songs express national sentiment for Israel, drawing a direct parallel between ancient Israel and modern nations like America is theologically problematic. Equating a modern nation-state with God’s chosen people in the Old Testament is a flawed and ultimately unproductive line of reasoning.
3. What musical models does the Bible offer for worship services?
Answer: The New Testament provides guidance on the types of music appropriate for Christian worship. Passages like Ephesians 5:18-19, Colossians 3:16, 1 Corinthians 14:15, and 1 Corinthians 14:26 offer insights:
- Ephesians 5:18-19: Emphasizes being “filled with the Spirit, speaking to one another in psalms and hymns and spiritual songs, singing and making melody with your heart to the Lord.” This verse highlights the importance of Spirit-filled worship expressed through various forms of song directed towards God.
- Colossians 3:16: Encourages letting “the word of Christ richly dwell within you, teaching and admonishing one another with psalms and hymns and spiritual songs, singing with thankfulness in your hearts to God.” This passage underscores the didactic and thankful nature of worship music, rooted in the Word of Christ and directed towards God.
- 1 Corinthians 14:15: Speaks of singing “with the spirit and… with the mind also,” advocating for worship that engages both emotional and intellectual understanding.
- 1 Corinthians 14:26: Describes gatherings where each participant might bring “a psalm, has a teaching, has a revelation, has a tongue, has an interpretation. Let all things be done for edification.” This verse points to the purpose of worship as edification and mutual building up within the community of believers.
The Psalms themselves were central to early church worship. The Old Testament Psalter primarily consists of prayers and praises to God, encompassing a range of human emotions and experiences directed towards divine worship. They serve as models for expressing faith, lament, thanksgiving, and seeking God’s wisdom.
4. Is there evidence of the early church singing non-worship or non-theological songs?
Answer: There is no known evidence suggesting that the early church incorporated songs into their worship that were not directly related to worship of God or the teaching of biblical and theological truths. The focus remained steadfastly on songs that glorified God, expressed faith, and built up the body of Christ in theological understanding.
Navigating the “Gray Area” of Patriotic Songs in Church
5. Does the inclusion of patriotic songs fall into a “gray area” governed by principles like Romans 14?
Answer: The issue of patriotic songs in worship exists in a nuanced space, partially resembling a “gray area” but with additional considerations. Since there is no explicit biblical prohibition against patriotic songs, nor a direct command to include them, the matter requires discernment based on broader biblical principles. However, these principles extend beyond the typical “gray area” discussions found in Romans 14 and 1 Corinthians 8 and 10, which primarily address personal conscience and avoiding offense in matters of indifference. The inclusion of patriotic songs touches on deeper theological themes related to the nature of worship, the global Christian community, and the message communicated through corporate worship. Therefore, it might be more accurately categorized as a “darker gray” or “lighter gray” issue, demanding careful theological and practical consideration beyond personal preference.
Sociological and Theological Implications of Patriotic Songs in Worship
6. What messages might patriotic songs convey in a church service to different groups?
Understanding the potential impact of patriotic songs requires considering various perspectives:
a) To a somewhat patriotic non-Christian American visitor:
-
Potential Positives:
- Thankfulness for national belonging: Communicates appreciation for the blessings of living in America.
- Call to civic commitment: May inspire a sense of responsibility towards the nation and its ideals of freedom.
- Support for leadership: Could be interpreted as an endorsement of national leaders.
- Perceived church relevance: Might suggest the church cares about national concerns.
-
Potential Negatives:
- National pride over humility: Could inadvertently foster national pride, which can be theologically problematic when it overshadows humility before God.
- National preference over global perspective: May imply a prioritization of American interests above others, contradicting a biblical emphasis on global Christian unity.
- Assumption of political alignment: Could wrongly suggest the church uniformly endorses specific governmental policies, particularly military actions, which is inaccurate given the diversity of Christian viewpoints on such matters (e.g., just war theory vs. pacifism).
b) To a patriotic American Christian attendee:
-
Potential Positives:
- All the potential positives listed for non-Christian visitors may also apply.
- Increased prayer for the nation: May inspire deeper intercession for the country and its leaders, including prayers for spiritual revival.
- Motivation for Christian civic engagement: Could encourage greater involvement in communicating Christian values in the public sphere.
-
Potential Negatives:
- All the potential negatives listed for non-Christian visitors may also apply.
- It’s crucial to acknowledge that not all American Christians identify as strongly patriotic due to various sociological and theological reasons, including disillusionment with government actions or a primary allegiance to the Kingdom of God. Churches must be sensitive to members who may feel uncomfortable with overt displays of nationalism in worship.
c) To a foreign visitor (Christian or non-Christian):
-
Potential Negatives:
- Heightened sense of foreignness: May intensify feelings of being an outsider or not belonging.
- Perceived prioritization of national over global concerns: Could convey that the church values national issues more than international or missional concerns.
- Fear or alienation: In certain global contexts, nationalistic expressions can evoke fear or discomfort.
- Theological confusion: Might create confusion about the universal nature of Christianity and its transcending of national boundaries.
-
Positive Outcomes:
- It is difficult to identify clear positive outcomes for foreign visitors when patriotic songs are incorporated into a worship service designed to be inclusive and welcoming to all. The focus should be on ensuring all attendees, regardless of nationality, feel equally valued and connected within the body of Christ.
7. How important is considering foreign visitors in our worship services?
Answer: Considering the experience of foreign visitors is critically important. A central aim of worship services, particularly in relation to unbelievers, is to create an environment where they can encounter God and recognize His presence among believers. As 1 Corinthians 14:25 states, unbelievers should have their “secrets of his heart…disclosed; and so he will fall on his face and worship God, declaring that God is certainly among you.” Singing patriotic songs may hinder this objective for unbelieving foreigners, potentially creating a barrier rather than a bridge to experiencing God’s presence.
Scripture consistently emphasizes care for foreigners and aliens (Leviticus 23:22; 2 Chronicles 6:32-33; Deuteronomy 10:19). Deuteronomy 10:19 explicitly commands, “And you are to love those who are aliens, for you yourselves were aliens in Egypt.” This biblical mandate underscores the importance of creating welcoming and inclusive worship environments for all, including those from different national backgrounds.
8. Are there cross-cultural communication principles in the Bible relevant to this discussion?
Answer: Yes, 1 Corinthians 9:19-23 offers highly relevant principles of cross-cultural communication:
“For though I am free from all men, I have made myself a slave to all, that I might win the more. And to the Jews I became as a Jew, that I might win Jews; to those who are under the Law, as under the Law, though not being myself under the Law, that I might win those who are under the Law; to those who are without law, as without law, though not being without the law of God but under the law of Christ, that I might win those who are without law. To the weak I became weak, that I might win the weak; I have become all things to all men, that I may by all means save some.”
Paul’s approach demonstrates a willingness to adapt and consider the perspectives of others to effectively communicate the Gospel. In the context of worship, this principle suggests we should be mindful of how our practices, including song selection, might be perceived and received by those from different cultural and national backgrounds. Prioritizing the Gospel message and the unity of the global church may sometimes require setting aside expressions that are primarily meaningful within a specific national context.
9. What biblical statements define our relationship with Christians of other nationalities?
Answer: The New Testament is replete with affirmations of deep allegiance and unity among Christians regardless of nationality or ethnicity. Conversely, the Bible lacks similar directives regarding nationalistic allegiance.
- Galatians 3:28: “There is neither Jew nor Greek, there is neither slave nor free man, there is neither male nor female; for you are all one in Christ Jesus.” This verse is foundational, emphasizing the transcending of national and social distinctions within the Christian community.
- Ephesians 2:14-19: Elaborates on the breaking down of barriers between people groups through Christ: “For He Himself is our peace, who made both groups into one, and broke down the barrier of the dividing wall… that in Himself He might make the two into one new man… So then you are no longer strangers and aliens, but you are fellow-citizens with the saints…” This passage highlights the creation of a new, unified community in Christ that supersedes national identities.
- Romans 1:14: Paul’s sense of obligation extends “both to Greeks and to Barbarians,” demonstrating a global perspective on Christian ministry.
- Philippians 3:20: Reminds believers, “For our citizenship is in heaven…,” placing primary allegiance in the heavenly kingdom rather than earthly nations.
These verses collectively emphasize that Christian identity and unity in Christ take precedence over national identity.
10. Do “gray area” principles from Romans 14 still apply?
Answer: Yes, principles from Romans 14 remain relevant, although this issue is not a simple “gray area.” Passages in Romans 14 offer guidance on navigating potentially divisive issues within the church:
- Romans 14:10: “But you, why do you judge your brother? Or you again, why do you regard your brother with contempt? For we shall all stand before the judgment seat of God.” This cautions against judgment and contempt towards fellow believers holding differing views.
- Romans 14:13: “Therefore let us not judge one another any more, but rather determine this—not to put an obstacle or a stumbling block in a brother’s way.” This emphasizes avoiding actions that might cause others to stumble in their faith.
- Romans 14:21: “It is good not to eat meat or to drink wine, or to do anything by which your brother stumbles.” This highlights the importance of self-restraint for the sake of others’ spiritual well-being.
- Romans 14:19: “So then let us pursue the things which make for peace and the building up of one another.” This directs believers to prioritize peace and mutual edification.
Applying these principles to patriotic songs in worship prompts reflection: Could singing patriotic songs cause foreign or even some American brothers and sisters to stumble or feel alienated? Could it inadvertently foster nationalistic pride that overshadows godly humility? These are crucial questions to consider in light of Romans 14.
Appropriate Songs for Worship During National Crisis
11. What types of songs and themes are suitable for worship during times of national crisis?
Answer: In moments of national crisis, worship music should primarily focus on themes that:
- Affirm the Sovereignty of God: Songs that emphasize God’s ultimate control and reign over all nations and events.
- Highlight God’s Care and Comfort: Songs that offer solace, peace, and assurance of God’s presence and love amidst suffering and uncertainty.
- Call to Trust in God: Songs that encourage unwavering faith and reliance on God in challenging circumstances.
- Urge National Repentance: Songs that call for introspection, confession of sin, and a turning back to God, both individually and corporately as a nation.
- Focus on Global Gospel Needs: Songs that broaden our perspective beyond national concerns to the urgent need for the Gospel to reach all peoples.
- Explicitly Glorify God: Above all, songs that center on the worship and adoration of God, ensuring that our focus remains on Him rather than nationalistic fervor.
By prioritizing these themes, churches can offer worship services that are theologically sound, pastorally sensitive, and globally minded, even in times of national crisis and heightened patriotic sentiment.
