The 1990s. A decade of grunge, Britpop, and the explosion of pop music. When we think of iconic songs from this era, a few anthems immediately spring to mind. But amongst the noise, there’s one track that consistently rises to the top in discussions about the decade’s best: “1979” by The Smashing Pumpkins.
Featured on their sprawling masterpiece Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness, “1979” stands out. Pitchfork, in their review of the album, aptly noted its futuristic sound amidst an album embracing 70s influences, describing it as a track that “sounds futuristic.” Beyond its sonic innovation, the song taps into a universal feeling of youthful nostalgia, making high school memories sound, dare we say, fondly remembered. Billy Corgan himself has emphasized its late addition to the album, yet its chorus possesses an undeniable urgency, perfectly capturing the “urgency of now” while simultaneously serving as a powerful piece of nostalgia, unlike any other song on Mellon Collie.
But does universal appeal translate to being the best? With over 159 million views on YouTube, its enduring legacy is undeniable. However, crowning it the best song of the 90s requires us to address two critical questions: Firstly, which songs define the 90s in our collective memory? And secondly, stripping away personal preferences, which song resonates with the widest audience?
When considering the most iconic songs of the 90s, a strong contender list emerges:
- “Smells Like Teen Spirit” – Nirvana
- “1979” – The Smashing Pumpkins
- “Wannabe” – Spice Girls
- “Paranoid Android” – Radiohead
- “Baby One More Time” – Britney Spears
This selection represents a diverse snapshot of the decade’s musical landscape, from grunge anthems to pop sensations and alternative rock masterpieces. While some might argue for the inclusion of Oasis’ “Wonderwall,” the songs listed above arguably hold a more significant and broader cultural impact.
Now, let’s examine which of these tracks boasts the widest appeal. “Smells Like Teen Spirit” is undoubtedly the iconic song of the 90s, the track most synonymous with the decade. Its cultural impact is immense, but its angst-ridden energy might not resonate with everyone across all demographics. “Wannabe,” a Spice Girls’ hit, was undeniably a global phenomenon, infectious and fun. However, its appeal might be more niche, primarily targeting a younger, pop-oriented audience. Its presence on contemporary playlists has also waned, questioning its long-term staying power. This highlights a crucial point: initial popularity doesn’t always guarantee enduring artistic relevance, a phenomenon observed with films like “The Artist” and “Avatar,” initially lauded but fading from cultural conversation over time.
Radiohead’s “Paranoid Android,” a progressive rock masterpiece, showcases incredible artistry and depth. Yet, its complex structure and darker themes might not translate into universal appeal. It’s unlikely to be found on a teen pop playlist or at a mainstream dance party. Similarly, while “Baby One More Time” launched Britney Spears into superstardom and dominated the late 90s youth scene, its bubblegum pop sound caters to a specific demographic, lacking the broader reach we’re seeking for the “best song of the 90s” title.
This brings us back to “1979”. This track possesses a unique alchemy. It’s catchy enough for mainstream appeal, yet retains an edgy, alternative sensibility. It sounds both futuristic with its shimmering synths and drum machines, and deeply nostalgic, evoking the bittersweet memories of youth. It bridges genres and generations. While personal biases always exist, the undeniable popularity, reflected in its massive YouTube views and continued airplay, suggests a deeper truth. “1979” transcends demographics and musical boundaries. It’s a song that resonates with a vast audience because it captures a universal feeling – the bittersweet ache of growing up, the yearning for simpler times, and the excitement of the future, all wrapped in a shimmering, unforgettable melody.
Therefore, while debates about “the best” are inherently subjective, when considering impact, enduring appeal, and cross-generational resonance, “1979” by The Smashing Pumpkins emerges as a compelling contender for the best song of the 1990s. Perhaps, deep down, your heart, and 159 million YouTube views, already knew it.
