The Bizarre Birth of “Fish Heads”: From a Disgusting Meal to Dr. Demento’s Hit
The genesis of “Fish Heads” is as unconventional as the song itself. It wasn’t born from heartbreak, social commentary, or typical musical inspiration. Instead, the spark for this iconic novelty track came from a less-than-appetizing dining experience at a Chinese restaurant. This anecdote alone hints at the whimsical and slightly absurd nature of Barnes & Barnes, the duo behind the song.
Inspired by Culinary Mishaps and Musical Madness
The story goes that Robert Haimer, one half of Barnes & Barnes, conceived the idea for “Fish Heads” after a particularly unpleasant meal. Details are scarce, but the experience clearly left a lasting impression, igniting a creative spark that led to the song’s unusual concept. This origin story perfectly encapsulates the spirit of novelty music, where the mundane and even the distasteful can be transformed into something hilariously memorable.
Barnes & Barnes: The Duo Behind the Demented Delight
Barnes & Barnes wasn’t just a random musical act; it was the brainchild of Bill Mumy and Robert Haimer. Bill Mumy, recognizable to many as a former child actor from iconic shows like Lost in Space and The Twilight Zone, possessed a musical side that often leaned towards the unconventional. Alongside his friend Robert Haimer, Mumy formed Barnes & Barnes as an outlet for their more eccentric and humorous musical inclinations. It was a project born from a desire to channel a “certain type of energy,” as Mumy himself described, resulting in music that was deliberately weird, funny, and irreverent.
Album cover of “Voobaha”, the debut album of Barnes & Barnes, featuring Bill Mumy and Robert Haimer.
Initially, Barnes & Barnes’ music was intended for personal amusement, a creative side project not necessarily destined for public consumption. However, Robert Haimer, a fan of The Dr. Demento Show, had the idea to submit some of their tracks to the legendary radio program that championed novelty and comedy music. This decision would prove to be pivotal in the trajectory of “Fish Heads.”
“Fish Heads” Takes Off: Dr. Demento and the Rise to Novelty Fame
Before “Fish Heads,” Barnes & Barnes sent another song to Dr. Demento, “The Vomit Song.” While it was deemed too extreme for airplay, their subsequent submission, “Fish Heads,” struck a chord immediately. Dr. Demento recognized the song’s unique and humorous qualities and began playing it on his show in 1978.
Dr. Demento’s Instant Recognition
Dr. Demento’s instincts were spot on. “Fish Heads” became an instant hit with his audience. Listeners began requesting the song from the very first night it aired, and calls flooded in with people even singing their own renditions. The Demented Music Database, a comprehensive archive of the show’s playlists, documents over 350 plays of “Fish Heads,” and this number doesn’t even include uncatalogued playlists. Dr. Demento himself recalled the immediate impact of the song:
I knew it would go over well on my show about 20 seconds into my first listen to it. Requests started coming in the same night I first played it, and continued to roll in steadily. After a few weeks of that, I knew it was going to be an all-time Dr Demento Show classic.
The Song’s Unique Appeal: Humor, Originality, and Catchiness
What made “Fish Heads” such a sensation? Dr. Demento pinpointed several key factors: its originality, its easily perceived humor, its catchy yet simple musical hook, and its clean production. He also noted a subtle satirical element, suggesting it could be interpreted as a parody of the popular, sped-up vocals of The Chipmunks. The combination of these elements created a novelty song that was not only funny but also surprisingly memorable and listenable.
/uploads/0718_chinese.jpg)
Image of fish heads on a plate in a Chinese restaurant, illustrating the unusual culinary inspiration for the novelty song.
The songwriting process itself was a collaborative effort. Robert Haimer is credited with the chorus, while Bill Mumy penned the verses. Even the song’s distinctive high-pitched vocals were a result of creative tension. Mumy advocated for speeding up the vocals, while Haimer initially preferred normal speed. Mumy’s vision prevailed, contributing to the song’s quirky and distinctive sound, solidifying its place in novelty music history.
The “Fish Heads” Music Video: A Surrealist Masterpiece by Bill Paxton
The “Fish Heads song” transcended audio and ventured into the visual realm with a music video that further cemented its cult status. Directed by a young Bill Paxton, years before his Hollywood fame, the video is a bizarre and captivating piece of surrealism that perfectly complements the song’s oddball nature.
A Low-Budget Vision Becomes an MTV Cult Classic
Bill Paxton’s involvement was crucial to the video’s unique aesthetic. He championed the project, even managing to get it aired on Saturday Night Live during a particularly chaotic season of the show. This early exposure, followed by regular rotation on MTV, propelled the “Fish Heads” video into the cultural consciousness. Paxton’s creative relationship with Barnes & Barnes extended beyond this video, as he directed several of their other music videos, each showcasing a similar surreal and offbeat style.
Dr. Demento’s Cameo and the Video’s Legacy
The “Fish Heads” music video is a visual feast of the strange and whimsical. It features cardboard cutouts, a fish head party, singers in trash bags, and fish heads sporting cowboy hats. Adding to the video’s charm is a cameo by Dr. Demento himself, playing a wino captivated by a fish head in an alleyway. Dr. Demento recounted his involvement, explaining that he was already friends with Barnes & Barnes when they conceived the video and created a role specifically for him.
/uploads/0718_fish.jpg)
Still from the “Fish Heads” music video featuring Dr. Demento in a cameo role as a wino.
The video’s enduring appeal is evident in its recognition, even decades later. Rolling Stone magazine included it in their 1993 list of the top 100 music videos. The “Fish Heads” video is not just a visual accompaniment to the song; it’s a work of art in its own right, a testament to low-budget creativity and surrealist humor. It can be found on Barnes & Barnes’ VHS “documentary” Zabagabee and Dr. Demento’s 20th Anniversary Collection VHS, ensuring its continued availability for fans of the bizarre and wonderful.
“Fish Heads” in Pop Culture: From The Simpsons to Punk Rock Revival
“Fish Heads” has permeated pop culture in unexpected ways, demonstrating its surprisingly broad appeal. Beyond its dedicated fanbase, the song has popped up in various media, reaching new audiences and solidifying its place as a novelty music touchstone.
Unexpected Appearances in Mainstream Media
One notable appearance is in The Simpsons, where Bart Simpson’s animosity towards Dr. Demento is humorously depicted. In the “Treehouse of Horror VII” episode, Homer sings “Fish Heads” while taking a bucket of fish heads to feed Bart’s “evil” twin, Hugo. This comedic reference in a mainstream animated series highlights the song’s recognition even outside of novelty music circles.
Another unexpected placement was in the AMC television show Halt and Catch Fire. In a season four episode, the song is heard playing from a cassette tape, showcasing its continued relevance and nostalgic appeal, even in a drama set in the tech world of the 1980s.
Even in the niche world of online music videos, “Fish Heads” has found its place. “The Bicycling Guitarist” video features a man riding a bicycle while playing a soft rock version of the song, adding another layer of bizarre interpretation to the already eccentric track.
/uploads/0718_nebula.jpg)
Image of the Fish Head Nebula from NASA, a celestial body that shares a name and resemblance with the song.
Interestingly, even a celestial object bears the name “Fish Head.” The Fish Head Nebula, a star-forming region in the Cassiopeia constellation, visually echoes the song’s title, further extending the quirky reach of “Fish Heads” into unexpected domains.
The Punk Rock Reimagining by Osaka Popstar
In a surprising twist, “Fish Heads” experienced a punk rock revival. John Cafiero, manager of The Misfits and lead singer of Osaka Popstar, spearheaded Dr. Demento Covered in Punk, a compilation album featuring punk versions of Dr. Demento classics. Osaka Popstar’s rendition of “Fish Heads” is a standout track, injecting a high-energy punk aesthetic into the novelty song. The cover even has its own music video, paying homage to the original “Fish Heads” video and various cinematic influences, bridging the gap between novelty and punk rock genres and introducing the song to a new generation of listeners.
The Lasting Legacy of “Fish Heads”: A Novelty Song That Endures
Despite Barnes & Barnes’ extensive catalog of quirky and humorous songs, “Fish Heads” remains their most iconic and enduring creation. While they never achieved mainstream commercial success, “Fish Heads” carved out a unique space in pop culture, fueled by its novelty charm and Dr. Demento’s early support.
Still a Dr. Demento Favorite
Even today, “Fish Heads” continues to reign supreme on The Dr. Demento Show. It remains the most requested song of all time, narrowly edging out Ogden Edsl’s “Dead Puppies.” Dr. Demento himself acknowledges the song’s special status, suggesting that it will be difficult for any future novelty song to surpass its enduring popularity on his show.
Why “Fish Heads” Remains a Cult Classic
The enduring appeal of “Fish Heads” lies in its unique blend of humor, originality, and catchiness. It’s a song that embraces the absurd, celebrates the bizarre, and manages to be both genuinely funny and surprisingly engaging. Whether you find it delightfully weird or simply off-the-wall, “Fish Heads” has undeniably left its mark on the landscape of novelty music and pop culture, proving that sometimes, the most unexpected creations are the ones that truly endure.
Conclusion: The enduring appeal of the “Fish Heads song” is a testament to the power of novelty music to capture the imagination and tickle the funny bone. From its humble beginnings inspired by a questionable meal to its status as a cult classic with a punk rock makeover, “Fish Heads” continues to swim against the current of mainstream music, proving that sometimes, the weirdest songs are the most memorable.
