Noah Kahan has cemented his place as a prominent voice in the folk-pop landscape, captivating listeners worldwide with his raw lyricism and emotionally resonant melodies. Hailing from Vermont, the 27-year-old artist initially garnered attention within niche circles but catapulted into mainstream consciousness with his poignant single, “Stick Season.” This breakthrough track paved the way for his critically acclaimed third album of the same name in October 2022, later expanded with the deluxe version, “Stick Season (We’ll All Be Here Forever),” in June 2023. However, Kahan wasn’t content to rest there. In a testament to the evolving nature of his artistry and the deep connection he forged with his audience through these songs, he unveiled “Stick Season (Forever)” in February 2024. This final iteration isn’t just a deluxe edition; it’s a reimagining, featuring eight collaborative tracks from the original “Stick Season” and a brand new bonus single, offering fresh perspectives and richer textures to an already beloved body of work.
“Stick Season (Forever)” underscores the transformative power of collaboration in music. Beyond fleeting viral remixes, Kahan’s approach embraces meaningful artistic partnerships, inviting artists across genres to engage with his narratives of mental health, complex relationships, and personal growth. For devoted fans and newcomers alike, this expanded album provides a compelling reason to revisit the world of “Stick Season” and delve deeper into the intricate tapestry of emotions woven throughout. Let’s embark on a track-by-track exploration of these collaborative masterpieces, ranking them based on their impact and contribution to the “Stick Season” saga.
1. “Call Your Mom (with Lizzy McAlpine)”
Topping the list is “Call Your Mom” featuring Lizzy McAlpine, a collaboration that transcends mere musical synergy to become a profoundly moving experience. For those deeply invested in emotionally charged songwriting, both Kahan and McAlpine are masters of crafting quiet devastation. This rendition elevates the original’s poignant narrative of supporting a friend battling inner turmoil. McAlpine’s voice intertwines seamlessly with Kahan’s, creating harmonies that are both ethereal and heart-wrenching. The song’s delicate beauty is amplified by their combined vocal prowess, transforming it into an anthem of empathy and unwavering friendship. The final chorus, in particular, is a masterclass in vocal layering, leaving a lasting emotional imprint on the listener long after the song concludes. This version arguably surpasses the original in its emotional depth and resonance, solidifying its place as a standout track within Kahan’s discography and a testament to the magic that can be created through thoughtful collaboration.
2. “Northern Attitude (with Hozier)”
Securing the second spot is “Northern Attitude” featuring Hozier, a pairing that felt almost inevitable for fans familiar with both artists’ penchant for introspective and cathartic songwriting. Anticipation for this collaboration had been building, fueled by their shared stage moments at festivals, and the final product more than delivers. “Northern Attitude” delves into the complex terrain of anxiety, fear, and the arduous journey of self-forgiveness. Hozier’s vocal contribution feels organically integrated, as if the song was always destined for this duet. His rendition of the second verse imbues the lyrics with an even more haunting quality, while the combined vocals during the chorus create a sonic landscape that is both expansive and intimate. The song’s stripped-down outro further emphasizes the raw vulnerability at its core, making this collaboration a powerful exploration of inner struggles and the search for peace. It’s a track that could easily find a home within Hozier’s own discography, a testament to the seamless blend of their artistic styles.
3. “Homesick (with Sam Fender)”
Claiming the third position is “Homesick” featuring Sam Fender, a collaboration rooted in mutual artistic admiration and shared thematic ground. Kahan himself has cited Fender as an inspiration for writing about his hometown and the intricate relationship one can have with their roots. This collaboration feels particularly fitting, then, as “Homesick” navigates the bittersweet emotions of longing for a place while acknowledging its complexities. Fender’s distinct vocal style injects a new energy into the track, and his rewritten second verse, reflecting his own experiences growing up in England, adds a layer of universality to the song’s core themes. Despite the geographical shift, the emotional core of small-town nostalgia, pride, and underlying tensions remains powerfully intact. For listeners who grapple with their own feelings about “home,” this version of “Homesick” resonates deeply, amplified by the raw vocal delivery of both Kahan and Fender.
4. “Paul Revere (with Gregory Alan Isakov)”
Landing in fourth place is “Paul Revere” featuring Gregory Alan Isakov, a collaboration that was highly anticipated by fans familiar with the introspective and evocative nature of both artists. “Paul Revere,” while a fan favorite, often flies under the radar in mainstream discussions of “Stick Season,” yet it perfectly encapsulates the album’s overarching themes of displacement and the elusive search for belonging. Isakov’s signature haunting vocals enhance the song’s sparse arrangement, creating an atmosphere that is both intimate and expansive. Given that Isakov’s music served as an inspiration for the original song, his presence on this version adds a layer of authenticity and depth. While the track builds subtly towards the outro, it maintains a sense of restraint, inviting listeners to sit with its quiet contemplation rather than erupt into cathartic release. The blend of Kahan and Isakov’s voices, particularly their contrasting vocal registers, creates a captivating sonic texture that lingers long after the song ends.
5. “She Calls Me Back (with Kacey Musgraves)”
Occupying the fifth spot is “She Calls Me Back” featuring Kacey Musgraves, a collaboration that injects a dose of playful energy into the “Stick Season” narrative. In contrast to the more melancholic tones of other tracks, “She Calls Me Back” explores the dynamics of a lingering, somewhat codependent relationship with a touch of self-aware humor. Musgraves embodies the role of the ex-girlfriend, her clear and bright vocals adding a new dimension to the song’s narrative. Her new verse provides a fresh perspective, while still complementing the original storyline. The song’s bridge and outro, with the iconic recitation of a phone number, remain lyrical highlights, amplified by the rhythmic drive of the percussion. This collaboration showcases a different facet of Kahan’s songwriting, highlighting his ability to blend vulnerability with lightheartedness, and the pairing with Musgraves proves to be a delightful and musically compelling match.
6. “Dial Drunk (with Post Malone)”
Securing the sixth position is “Dial Drunk” featuring Post Malone, a collaboration that initially raised eyebrows but ultimately delivered a unique and intriguing sonic experiment. The pairing of Kahan, often playfully nicknamed “Folk Malone,” and the genre-bending Post Malone is unexpected, yet it yields a surprisingly cohesive track. “Dial Drunk” paints a vivid picture of longing and vulnerability, set against a backdrop of a driving beat and catchy melody. Post Malone’s contribution, featuring a rap-infused second verse, initially feels somewhat out of place within the folk-rooted soundscape. However, the choruses reveal an unexpected vocal blend, with their voices creating a raspy, textured harmony that adds a raw edge to the song’s emotional core. While this collaboration might not resonate as deeply with all listeners as the original solo version, it stands as a testament to Kahan’s willingness to experiment and push genre boundaries, resulting in a track that is both unconventional and captivating.
7. “You’re Gonna Go Far (with Brandi Carlile)”
Ranking seventh is “You’re Gonna Go Far (Kid)” featuring Brandi Carlile, a collaboration that, while featuring a powerhouse vocalist, doesn’t quite reach the heights of some other pairings on the album. While many initially speculated about a Marcus Mumford collaboration, the inclusion of Brandi Carlile is undoubtedly a significant addition. Carlile’s vocal prowess is undeniable, and her new second verse expands upon the song’s themes of ambition, leaving home, and the enduring pull of roots. However, at times, Carlile’s vocal embellishments, while technically impressive, tend to overshadow the core melody and emotional nuances of the song. While her voice is undeniably gorgeous, the overall impact of this collaboration feels slightly less cohesive compared to others on the album, placing it lower in this ranking despite its undeniable vocal strengths.
8. “Everywhere, Everything (with Gracie Abrams)”
Rounding out the collaborative tracks at the eighth position is “Everywhere, Everything” featuring Gracie Abrams. This song, lyrically reminiscent of Hozier’s “In a Week” in its exploration of morbidly romantic devotion, is a sweet and tender ballad about eternal love. While “Everywhere, Everything” is a well-crafted song in its own right, it isn’t a standout track from the original “Stick Season” album for all listeners. Abrams’ voice is undeniably pretty and adds a delicate touch to the second verse. However, her softer vocal delivery somewhat diminishes the powerful impact of the chorus, where the unison vocals lack the dynamic punch present in the solo version. Lyrically, the song remains strong, but vocally, this collaboration doesn’t quite capture the full emotional depth of the original, placing it at the lower end of this ranking.
BONUS: “Forever”
Beyond the collaborative tracks, “Stick Season (Forever)” also gifts listeners with a brand new bonus single, aptly titled “Forever.” This titular track serves as a perfect culmination of the “Stick Season” era, encapsulating the album’s journey of growth and transformation. Kahan has been teasing “Forever” in live performances, building anticipation for its official release. The song’s core message revolves around shifting perspectives, particularly regarding the concept of “forever.” Musically, “Forever” is dynamic and multifaceted, moving seamlessly between introspective acoustic moments and layered folk instrumentation. It’s a cyclical and evolving piece, acting as both a reflection on the past and an optimistic gaze towards the future. “Forever” stands apart from the ranked collaborations, existing as a poignant and moving musical statement that perfectly concludes this chapter of Noah Kahan’s artistic journey.
“Stick Season (Forever)” is more than just a deluxe album; it’s a testament to the enduring power of Noah Kahan’s songwriting and his ability to connect with audiences on a deeply personal level. This final installment of the “Stick Season” cycle serves as a fitting farewell to this era, leaving fans eager to witness what Kahan will create next. As Kahan himself eloquently stated, “The word ‘forever’ used to terrify me… Now though, I’ve found forever to mean there is limitless possibility. There is so much joy in the world, waiting to be found. That is something that ‘Stick Season’ has shown me, that this year has shown me…. I hope you enjoy these songs, I hope they continue to find you in the times you most need them, like they did for me. I do not know what is next, but I’m glad I get forever to find it.” “Stick Season (Forever)” is readily available on all streaming platforms, inviting listeners to immerse themselves in its sonic landscape and emotional depth.
