Backstreet Boys, the iconic boy band that defined an era, boasts a discography packed with hits and hidden gems. While their official singles dominated the charts and airwaves, devoted fans know that some album tracks possessed just as much, if not more, single potential. Inspired by a recent fan Q&A with Nick, Howie, and AJ, where they discussed songs they wished were singles, this article dives deep into the Backstreet Boys catalog to spotlight those overlooked tracks that truly deserved their moment in the single spotlight.
The Red Album (Backstreet Boys – US Debut)
For their US debut album, while “I’ll Never Break Your Heart” is a classic ballad, “I Wanna Be With You” screams missed opportunity. This track is pure 90s pop perfection – undeniably catchy, upbeat, and brimming with youthful energy. Imagine the music video possibilities! While “I’ll Never Break Your Heart” eventually found its footing, “I Wanna Be With You” had instant hit potential written all over it. It’s the kind of song that gets stuck in your head after just one listen and embodies the fun, energetic spirit of early Backstreet Boys.
Backstreet’s Back
Moving onto Backstreet’s Back, the obvious fan-favorite choice is “10,000 Promises”. This song is more than just a track; it’s an experience. Hauntingly beautiful and emotionally resonant, “10,000 Promises” possesses a timeless quality that rivals even their biggest hits like “I Want It That Way.” Nick Carter himself has acknowledged its single-worthy status, and for good reason. Its powerful vocals, evocative melody, and mature themes could have cemented its place as a definitive Backstreet Boys classic on a global scale.
Backstreet Boys album covers featuring official singles, sparking a fan discussion about songs that deserved to be singles.
Beyond “10,000 Promises,” “That’s The Way I Like It” also shines as a strong contender. Upbeat, undeniably fun, and a staple in their tours and cruises, this track demonstrates the Backstreet Boys’ ability to deliver infectious, high-energy pop. While “If You Want It To Be Good Girl (Get Yourself A Bad Boy)” is a fun album track, “That’s The Way I Like It” has the broader appeal and sing-along quality that defines a successful single.
Millennium
Many might immediately think of “Don’t Want You Back” from Millennium, and while it’s a fantastic, edgy track, “It’s Gotta Be You” deserves serious consideration. This song is pure earworm candy. Its infectious melody, playful lyrics, and undeniable charm make it an instant mood booster. Imagine a vibrant, fun-filled music video accompanying “It’s Gotta Be You” – it could have been a lighter, more playful single release from Millennium, showcasing a different facet of the album’s sound. While “Don’t Want You Back” would have been a bolder, more unconventional choice, “It’s Gotta Be You” offered instant, undeniable pop appeal.
Black & Blue
Black & Blue is home to a track that screams “missed single opportunity” – “Get Another Boyfriend”. This song is pure attitude and swagger, showcasing a more mature and confident Backstreet Boys. The live performances of “Get Another Boyfriend” in their residency prove its enduring energy and crowd-pleasing power. Following the darker, edgier vibe of “The Call” music video, a video for “Get Another Boyfriend” could have been equally visually striking and further solidified their evolution as artists. It’s a high-energy, empowering anthem that deserved its time to shine as a single.
Never Gone
From Never Gone, while “I Still” was released as a single internationally, its omission in the US market remains a baffling decision. However, looking at tracks that were never singles anywhere, “Song For The Unloved” stands out as a truly exceptional and deeply moving song. This powerful ballad is emotionally raw, lyrically poignant, and showcases the Backstreet Boys’ vocal harmonies at their finest. Many fans believe “Song For The Unloved” possessed Grammy-worthy potential. Its heartfelt message and mature sound could have resonated deeply with a wider audience and demonstrated the Backstreet Boys’ artistic depth beyond pure pop.
Unbreakable
Unbreakable is an album packed with underrated gems. “Unsuspecting Sunday Afternoon” is a unique and atmospheric track that truly stands out. Its distinctive sound, coupled with the album’s acapella intro, creates a captivating listening experience. Visualizing a music video that incorporated the acapella intro and the song’s unique vibe is exciting. Furthermore, “Everything But Mine” deserves a nod. While radio landscape was challenging for boy bands in 2007/2008, this upbeat and lyrically rich track could have offered a refreshing and energetic single option. Its catchy melody and relatable themes might have helped them break through and reconnect with a broader audience.
This Is Us
From This Is Us, while Nick Carter himself championed “Undone,” “Masquerade” presents a truly unique and imaginative single possibility. Imagine a Halloween-themed music video for “Masquerade,” a spiritual successor to the iconic “Everybody (Backstreet’s Back)” video. The song’s theatrical flair and mysterious vibe lend themselves perfectly to a visually stunning and memorable video concept. While “Bigger” had a strong music video, “Masquerade” offered a more creative and thematically rich single option, tapping into a fun, seasonal angle. While “Trouble” remains a beloved unreleased track among hardcore fans, “Masquerade” from the official album tracklist holds immense untapped single potential.
In A World Like This
For In A World Like This, the title track was indeed a perfect lead single. However, “Make Believe” emerges as a standout choice for a follow-up single. This song possesses a magical, escapist quality that sets it apart. Its dreamy atmosphere and heartfelt lyrics could have resonated strongly on adult contemporary radio. The lyrical imagery and emotional depth of “Make Believe” offered significant music video potential, allowing for a visually captivating and emotionally engaging release. It’s a song that transports you and showcases a more mature, introspective side of the Backstreet Boys.
What Backstreet Boys Songs do you think deserved to be singles? Share your thoughts and opinions in the comments below! Let’s continue the conversation and celebrate the depth and breadth of the Backstreet Boys’ incredible musical catalog.
